I got myself into a mini-debate over on SlickDeals a while back about people who write checks at retail stores. I’m not a terribly patient person anyway, so retail check writers annoy me to no end. It takes much longer to write out a check than it does to swipe a card or even count out cash, and then there is the whole ritual the cashier must go through of checking ID, writing down information, etc. I’ve even seen some stores now that require manager approval on checks, so that kills at least another three minutes there.
In my view the check is an outdated method of payment, only useful for paying the occasional bill, your taxes, and minor things that they don’t take credit cards for (lawn service, paying family members/friends, etc.). There is no advantage to using checks in a retail environment. How do I come to this conclusion? Glad you asked…
- Value: You are paying the same amount at the register regardless of payment method, so there is certainly no advantage to writing checks.
- Speed: Credit and debit cards are way quicker than checks, even if the cashier checks your ID to the cardholder name. Even cash transactions where change has to be made are quicker than the typical check transaction.
- Record keeping: Now matter how you pay, you should be able to get a receipt, which provides evidence of the transaction if you need it for taxes, expense reimbursement, etc. Debit and credit cards are even better since you also get the listing of transactions on your account statement.
- Privacy: Do you really want the kid down at the Wal-Mart having access to your personal information including account number? You do realize that is all the information they need to access the funds in your account, right?
- Liability: Related to the point above, what happens if someone gets your account information? If you used a credit card, you are technically only responsible for the first $50, and in most cases the credit card issuer won’t even make you pay that. You also have the luxury of not being out the money while the issue is being resolved. Debit cards and checks are a different story, where the bank can hold the funds in question while it completes its investigation, meaning you don’t have access to your money. And it is a lot harder to prove a transfer was unauthorized if they used you account number to access the funds directly.
For the record, it annoys me even more when people wait until the cashier has completely finished ringing the transaction to search for the checkbook and beginning writing the check, as if it is a surprise that you actually have to pay for your purchases! But of course my ire in this instance isn’t limited to check writers, but any idiot who waits that long to begin fumbling through their purse/wallet/pockets for their method of payment. All of them should be taken into the parking lot and beaten with their purchases.
So am I missing something here about the virtues of checks? Do I just need to be more patient with the old people and the stupid when they whip out the checkbook?